Jan & Tony’s Pizza

Ordered a large meat lovers and a large supreme for a work party. Pick up was perfectly on time, service was excellent. Crust and sauce were tasty, very good. Only thing was pizzas were a little greasy, couldn't open the juice bottle I had, hands kept slipping even after napkin wipes. No big deal, just be sure to have lots of napkins on hand. These guys don't skimp on the toppings either which is great. Will be ordering J&T again soon..

A very spacious and clean dining area awaits all customers, looks recently remodeled or a new addition. The staff is super kind and friendly, our pizzas were taking a little longer so they brought us some cookies. They have some really cool speciality pizzas I'd like to try like a mac&cheese or taco pizza. Subs and pasta options, their spaghetti entree is only $6.95, what a bargain, right? The pizza tasted great with a good crispy and soft touch. Loved the crispy crust and the pizza came out fresh and hot (love hot pizza). The staff checked on us twice which you gotta love that touch, making sure we are pleased with our purchase (I feel like that is a lost art) Come check it out, it's gooooddddd!!

This place is truly a hidden gem. We ordered a ton of food for 2 people because we wanted to try everything, and it was worth every penny. The owner took our order and waited on us throughout the experience and was so nice and attentive. If you are thinking about going here, it is a must!!!

Great food with good service. Our Family has been eating from Jan & Tony's Pizza and many other dishes and treats for years. Locals FAV Spot. Enjoy AWESOME LUNCH SPECIALS

We went here on a Thursday night for the first time & were EXTREMELY impressed! This was our first time here, & we wanted to try something new. From the moment we walked in, it was 5-star treatment! Service was VERY friendly & helpful. We placed our order at the counter & went to sit in the dining room to wait for a kitchen staff member to come out with our pizzas. The wait was approximately 20 mins. The pizza we ate, was a large deluxe & it was fantastic! Plenty of sauce, plentiful toppings with good distribution & nice thin, crispy crust. Wonderful taste. Just excellent. I overheard the Mgr. talking to my fiancée about how they had been in the area now for approximately 30+ years. HOW HAVE I NEVER HEARD ABOUT THIS GEM OF A PIZZA SHOP?!? This place is GREAT & you should take some time & drive out to Plain City, OH & check this place out! (Check out their website for full menu.)

This restaurant has been a landmark in Plain City at the corner of 42 &161. THEY MOVED to a strip mall off 161 next to Love Joy Grocery Store. Order & pay at the counter then move to your left and sit in the clean dining room. Service was friendly and the food came to our table fast and hot! We both ordered the pizza lunch specials. I had the blanched mushrooms; my favorite! Hubs ordered pepperoni. It was old world pepperoni with those little curled up cups of grease. Also included was a small romain salad and a can of pepsi. Choices there included Mug Root Beer. Dr Pepper, Mountain Dew, Pepsi and more with the option to upgrade to a bottle. Plenty of food. I would absolutely return to try more items on their menu. Sorry, no pictures...I was too hungry and dug in!

We ordered a large calzone, homemade lasagna with two meatballs and breadsticks, and chef salad. We decided to dine in rather than take out. Dining room was clean, has 8 or 9 tables and a TV that was on ESPN. The food was pretty good. My favorite part was the breadsticks that came with the homemade lasagna. The salad was smaller then I anticipated. The large calzone was huge! We will have leftovers for lunch and dinner tomorrow. The lasagna hit the spot; I had a craving, it was a nice recipe. Nothing too fancy but great flavor. The only drink options are cans or 2 liters of pop, bottles of sweet or unsweetened tea, or bottled water. I wish they had fountain drinks for dine in customers. The staff was great! We will likely dine here again or order takeout.